Skip to main content

Death of Democracy legally NO, democratically YES!

There are times when we do something and regret it immediately. There are also times when we regret we did something long back. Some of our steps backfire on us and some of our actions literally mock us. Today is such a day for Mr. Rahul Gandhi. A reluctant politician who was given the job of carrying forward the legacy of his family, of leading the Congress party and the nation. The man who has immense courage to take up all the trolling and criticism. Pappu as people popularly call him. Yet again, stand in the parliament and give a speech, just to be criticized and trolled right after it ends. The man is no longer a  parliamentarian.

Rahul Gandhi's conviction which followed his disqualification came as a big shock for most of us. For sure, it is the most exciting news for any common Indian news viewer. The mere thought that one of the biggest politicians, the so-called PM face of the Congress party was convicted in a petty defamation case by a district court is startling. Well, no one can actually question the conviction by the court but the actual cacophony is around his disqualification from the Lok Sabha. Well for sure, we see the entire opposition united and questioning Rahul Gandhi's disqualification. The Congress Party has taken a feisty stand on the issue and termed the event as the 'Black Day for Indian Democracy'. Various Twitter handles of the congress party and its leaders have shown their support for Mr.Gandhi by changing their profile photo to a picture saying "Daro maat Rahul Gandhi". The all-around support from all the parties in opposition and the lightning speed with which Mr.Gandhi was debarred from parliament makes us skeptical. Is it legally valid is the elephant in the room?

Politicians are people one tries to approach to get away with court cases or arrests. These things have changed in recent times with CBI and ED teams raiding opposition leaders in a row. Well, we do not know if it is a misuse of power by the ruling BJP or actually the normal routine investigation by the constitutional offices. What we have some faith in is the legal system of India. Mr.Gandhi's open public remark on the entire Modi community certainly, in my limited understanding, calls for a defamation charge. He has been convicted and sentenced to two years imprisonment along with a fine. Can he be disqualified or does he gets 30 or 90 days' time to apply in a higher court? In very simple words, a convict MP or MLA does get a chance to appeal in the higher court but he can be disqualified from his seat immediately once convicted for two years or more. This comes after 2013, Lily Thomas vs Union of India verdict in which the Supreme court held that section 8(4) of the Representation of People Act 1951 is unconstitutional. 

So what now? Rahul Gandhi definitely has been granted 30 days' time by the Surat session court to file an appeal in Gujrat High Court but currently, his disqualification is legally valid. He now can stay an MP only if there is a stay on conviction by the High court. A mere suspension of a two-year sentence is not enough. The road ahead seems difficult for Rahul Gandhi and the Congress party, but more so for India at large. Fortunately, unfortunately; Rahul Gandhi is the only face of national opposition in our country. A country of 140 million ruled by one single party and no national opposition is a warning sign for a healthy democracy. There can be questions on whether Rahul Gandhi qualifies as good opposition, but sadly India today has only him as opposition nationally. His disqualification, however legal, is not good for Indian democracy. 




          


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

STIGMA AROUND HOMOSEXUALITY IN INDIA

I was dismayed when I saw a pamphlet in the local newspaper which claimed that a certain medicine could cure the disease of homosexuality. Similarly one can find numerous youtube videos of people giving tips to cure homosexuality. Homosexuality is not a disease and hence it is not something that can be cured or should be cured. There is a lot of stigma around sex and gender in Indian society. Anyone who does not fit into the so-called norms that society has created has to go through the torment of his own family, friends, and relatives. Homosexuality is the attraction of people of the same sex. A homosexual person, unlike a heterosexual person, does not feel attraction for the opposite gender. It is something that is characterized in a person since birth and is only realized by a person later when they mature. There are a lot of myths about homosexuality in India. Those myths are not even addressed in our society because it is taboo to talk about homosexuality. This has given rise to h...
Post a Comment
Read more

What's a court like? My first visit to Session's court.

What is a court like? Is it anything like the courtroom like we have seen in our bollywood movies? Does the judge say "order order" every now and then? Not at all. Being a first generation lawyer and a person who luckily never got into any court cases, I had never visited a court. Now that I have chosen to be a lawyer, I was really interested to see the court proceedings. Luckily, I went to the Bombay Session and Civil court today as our college lectures got cancelled. There is one thing that many people donot know is that anyone can visit court and listen the hearings that are held( except for certain crimes where camera trials are held). One need to have a valid identity proof to enter the court.  Bombay session court is huge and old. The British architecture makes the court look magnificent. There are various court rooms in the premises and each court room is assigned a particular type of case. For example , all cases related to Narcotics are dealt in court room number 44....
Post a Comment
Read more

I should have helped?

 It was a humid day in July in New Delhi, India. It was around 3 p.m. that it started raining which was a respite from the scorching sun of the afternoon. I wished to sit in the balcony of my PG and have some chai-biscuit but I had no time to appreciate the rain. I was running late. I had my coaching at 4 p.m. and I had not yet taken bath. It isn't like taking bath was necessary but I could not go with my messy hair with Riya recently passing smiles at me. I quickly took a bath, packed my bag, and checked my phone for the time. It was 3:15. Also I saw a text from my friend, Darshan, that he had already left for the coaching. It was our legal studies class and a new teacher was going to take up the topic of constitutional laws.     The little rain did no good to the weather. Although the sun had gone, the weather had become incorrigibly humid. I was quite late and so I had to walk briskly to the metro station. The long queue at the metro station was an add-on to my de...
Post a Comment
Read more